Charts showing Fantasy and Horror award finalists and their rating counts on Goodreads
Commentary
I'm afraid I don't follow fantasy or horror at all, so these charts are
more likely than others to have errors e.g. if the wrong editions
have been picked up.
As of August 2020, there is no proper entry in ISFDB for 2016 finalist The
Telling, seemingly on the grounds that it is a
non-speculative
gothic mystery; at this time it has 669 ratings on Goodreads.
Commentary